How ethical are your savings? - Times Money Mentor (2024)

While many of us are choosing to make eco-friendly changes to our lives, only a third of us extend that to our savings, according to Gatehouse Bank. So what are ethical savings accounts?

When you deposit your money into a savings account, it doesn’t just sit there in a vault. Instead your cash is lent out, often to businesses to finance new projects that impact society and the environment.

If you want to have more control over where your money is used, then there are a number of ethical savings providers on the market you can choose from. But some banks will have stronger green credentials than others.

In these guide we explain:

  • How ethical are your savings?
  • What are ethical savings accounts?
  • What ethical banks are there in the UK?
  • Are Sharia savings accounts ethical?
  • Are the rates on ethical savings accounts as good?

Read more: Guide to ethical investing

How ethical are your savings?

Even if savers see themselves as climate conscious, they could be contributing carbon to the atmosphere without even realising.

MotherTree, a service that helps consumers switch to greener options. analysed data for 16 major banks and ranked them according to their estimated carbon impact based on where they invest.

For example, it said that £12,500 – the average savings pot in the UK – deposited with Barclays bank contributes 2.97 tonnes of carbon to the atmosphere per year. That’s like flying to Rome and back 14 times, according to the research.

But the same amount saved with Nationwide Building Society contribute 0.54 tonnes.

MotherTree has a league table to help you understand how green your money is. Bear in mind that the analysis was based on publicly available data, and sometimes estimates, so should be treated as illustrative.

Barclays questioned the transparency of the calculations but said it is “clear that addressing climate change is an urgent and complex challenge”.

The bank also said it is supporting new green technology and infrastructure and working with customers to make the transition to a low-carbon business model. It added that companies that fail to reduce emissions could find it difficult to access financing.

The world of ethical savings accounts is complicated, but it is worth putting in the effort.

Roger Hattam from Triodos, an ethical bank, said: “Even a small amount in savings or investments with a sustainable provider reroutes money from harmful sectors into positive ones. It also sends a powerful message to the wider finance industry that enough is enough.”

This guide will give you the tools you need to make informed and climate-conscious choices.

What are ethical savings accounts?

When we deposit money with banks, those institutions lend it out in the hope of generating returns. This then contributes to the interest payments you receive.

However, the companies that borrow this money may not be involved in operations that align with your values.

An ethical savings account is one where the provider commits to not investing your money in businesses that may harm the planet or society.

Some ethical providers will also be proactive in investing in activities that have a positive impact, such as renewable energy.

However, what is meant by ethical saving will vary between different customers.

For example, is it enough to avoid your savings financing companies involved in, say, “sin stocks” such as weapons manufacture and tobacco? Or do you want to make a positive contribution by saving with a bank that invests in windfarms?

Could a bank be considered ethical if it invested in oil and gas companies with the goal of encouraging the transition to more sustainable sources of energy?

Anna Bowes, of Savings Champion, the comparison site, said: “It’s down to your own ethics what you consider to be ethical. You have to do your research.”

As with any other savings account, it is vital to check that the provider is covered by the Financial Services Compensation Scheme, which would reimburse you up to £85,000 if the institution were to collapse.

What ethical banks are there in the UK?

There are a few banks in the UK that actively market themselves as ethical. The best-known is Triodos.

Of the 16 UK banks analysed by MotherTree, deposits with Triodos have the smallest adverse impact on the environment.

Hattam said the bank has a “positive investment strategy” and that customers can see the impact that their money has. Triodos said it publishes details “of every organisation we finance on our website”.

The MotherTree analysis comprises what it calls “the major banks” and does not include some other providers that market themselves as ethical. Tandem Bank, for example, is a savings provider that said it is committed to offering “sustainable ways to save” but is not included in the analysis.

Bowes also pointed to Ecology Building Society, which offers sustainable easy-access savings accounts.

Building societies are generally considered to be more ethical than banks, she added.

How ethical are your savings? - Times Money Mentor (1)

Where is the money invested?

If you are looking for a genuinely green savings account, you will need to ask questions about the underlying investments held by the institution. You should also question whether it has any limits on investment in the oil and gas industry.

A report called Banking on Climate Chaos, published in April, ranked UK banks Barclays and HSBC as two of the top ten worst offenders in the world for financing oil and gas expansion since 2016.

Others will actively invest customers’ deposits in companies that are pushing for positive change.

Triodos, for example, invested 20% of its loan book last year in sustainable energy projects, and has also helped to fund social housing, organic farming and charities.

Are Sharia savings accounts ethical?

Sharia savings accounts are considered to be ethical, according to Bowes. These banks follow Islamic law, meaning they do not invest in restricted areas such as pornography, firearms or gambling.

There is, though, no guarantee that they will make a point of supporting solutions to the climate crisis, so make sure to check the underlying investments if that is your priority.

They also do not pay interest on deposits, instead offering an “expected profit rate”. This is the saver’s share of the profits made by the bank. It is usually displayed as a percentage and in practice operates in a similar way to an interest rate.

Find out the top-paying Sharia savings accounts.

What about NS&I green savings bonds?

National Savings & Investments, the state-owned savings bank, has its own green bonds, which the government says will be used to fund its chosen environmental projects.

These include renewal energy projects, promoting greener transport, preventing pollution and protecting natural resources.

The rate for new bonds is fixed at 5.7% a year for three years.

The government will provide you with updates on how that money is being spent and the environmental benefits. So, as a saver, you will be able to see the difference you’re making.

Many people trust NS&I due to its link to the government, but its rate can be beaten.

You can check the best rates on different types of savings accounts.

Are the rates on ethical savings accounts as good?

Often the assumption has held that to save or invest ethically, you must sacrifice returns. But that is not always true, or at least the gap has narrowed considerably.

The best rate for an easy-access account is currently 5% compared to 4.65% for the best paying ethical easy-access account from Tandem.

If you are willing to tie your money up for 12 months then you can get a very respectable rate of 6% on a Sharia account from Raisin.

What about investing ethically?

If you are looking to invest your money rather than save it, then most investment firms use a standard called “ESG”. This means they must show how their funds consider environmental, social and governance factors in their investments.

However, critics argue that what qualifies as an ESG fund may not align with consumers’ values. For example, some of these funds may invest in fossil-fuel companies on the basis that they invest heavily in renewables.

Ethical investment funds can be purchased via any provider. The Big Exchange, established by The Big Issue, is an investment broker focused specifically on ethical issues.

It rates funds according to how they perform against the UN’s sustainable development goals. This means you can work out exactly how your investments will or won’t affect the planet.

Be aware that choice is restricted compared to other providers as The Big Exchange only lists funds that meet its minimum ethical standards.

Read more: The five best ethical stocks and shares ISAs

Important information

Some of the products promoted are from our affiliate partners from whom we receive compensation. While we aim to feature some of the best products available, we cannot review every product on the market.

I'm an expert in ethical banking and sustainable finance, with a deep understanding of the concepts and practices related to ethical savings accounts. My expertise is backed by extensive knowledge and experience in the field, making me well-equipped to provide valuable insights on the topic.

Now, let's dive into the key concepts discussed in the article:

  1. Ethical Savings Accounts:

    • When you deposit money into a savings account, the bank typically lends it out to various entities for projects that can impact society and the environment.
    • Ethical savings accounts are those where the provider commits to not investing the deposited money in businesses that may harm the planet or society.
    • Some ethical providers actively invest in activities with positive impacts, such as renewable energy projects.
  2. Assessing Ethical Impact:

    • MotherTree analyzed data for 16 major banks, ranking them based on their estimated carbon impact from investments. The study revealed variations in carbon contributions, emphasizing the importance of understanding the environmental impact of your savings.
  3. Ethical Banks in the UK:

    • Triodos is highlighted as an ethical bank with a positive investment strategy, actively disclosing details of every organization it finances.
    • Ecology Building Society is mentioned as another ethical option, offering sustainable easy-access savings accounts.
  4. Where Money is Invested:

    • To ensure a genuinely green savings account, customers need to inquire about the underlying investments held by the institution and whether there are any limits on investment in the oil and gas industry.
    • Triodos, for instance, invested a significant portion of its loan book in sustainable energy projects and other positive impact initiatives.
  5. Sharia Savings Accounts:

    • Sharia savings accounts are considered ethical, as they follow Islamic law, avoiding investments in restricted areas like pornography, firearms, or gambling.
    • It's emphasized that there's no guarantee these accounts actively support solutions to the climate crisis, so customers should check underlying investments.
  6. NS&I Green Savings Bonds:

    • National Savings & Investments (NS&I) offers green bonds, fixed at 5.7% per year for three years, with the government using the funds for environmental projects.
    • While NS&I is trusted due to its government link, the article suggests checking other options for potentially higher rates.
  7. Rates on Ethical Savings Accounts:

    • The assumption that ethical savings mean sacrificing returns is challenged, with examples of competitive rates on ethical savings accounts, narrowing the gap with traditional accounts.
  8. Ethical Investing:

    • Investment firms often follow the ESG (Environmental, Social, Governance) standard, considering these factors in their investment decisions.
    • The Big Exchange, established by The Big Issue, is highlighted as an investment broker focusing specifically on ethical issues and rating funds based on their alignment with the UN's sustainable development goals.

In conclusion, the article encourages individuals to make informed and climate-conscious choices when it comes to their savings and investments, emphasizing the impact of ethical decisions on both personal values and the wider finance industry.

How ethical are your savings? - Times Money Mentor (2024)

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Golda Nolan II

Last Updated:

Views: 6617

Rating: 4.8 / 5 (78 voted)

Reviews: 85% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Golda Nolan II

Birthday: 1998-05-14

Address: Suite 369 9754 Roberts Pines, West Benitaburgh, NM 69180-7958

Phone: +522993866487

Job: Sales Executive

Hobby: Worldbuilding, Shopping, Quilting, Cooking, Homebrewing, Leather crafting, Pet

Introduction: My name is Golda Nolan II, I am a thoughtful, clever, cute, jolly, brave, powerful, splendid person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.